not the kind of girl you take home

   
  7/10/01
   
 
Your Maryanne did not betray you, but you betrayed her; and left her to die like a punk for your ideals, broken and alone on the streets of Paris, or Berlin, or where ever the "Apprenticeship of Wilhelm Meister" started off. You were distracted off your bourgeois course for an instant, a handful of years, seduced by the glitz and glamour of theater and high living, but when your mistress is killed by that same life, you will return to your own, become respectable, and marry a lady; you will make compromises, and smile bemusedly at the follies of your youth, and shake your head that you could ever live in such a frivolous manner.
 
 
But it wasn't to be one of the theater that brought your mistress here, it wasn't the magic of words, the traditions of the craft-- she was a pretty woman and a wild one, and she made sure men paid for what they got from her. She was ambitious, ambitious enough not to starve, ambitious enough not to die as poor as she had been born.
 
 
At least, she was until she met you.
 
 
You did not know her name, probably, not her real one, and yet you think you know her? You meet her for a moment and suddenly your dreams are hers. Perhaps all she wants is a little legitimacy, a little comfort, a little friendship; she lives in a world of illusion, after all, where fortunes crumble as quickly as they rise and she holds her corsage before her like a shield, or a pledge-- she is beautiful, but she has no rights without a patron, without money behind her. And you come here, with nothing she needs, and give her something far more terrible; you offer her love and convince her it is better than life. But what do you; a naive, educated young man, know about life? You will suffer for the gift you've given her, the wound to your pride that comes from being in love with a whore. She will betray your trust out of love and you will hate her. Perhaps your family approached her and appealed to her sense of honor, perhaps some plot she is entangled with demands her life for yours, perhaps she betrays you simply because she understands that it is inevitable that you will one day grow to hate her, and she wants to make the break as clean and quick as possible. But you will not die of it.
 
 
She will die, she always does. Violetta, Camille, Maryanne, Satine, she will die because you told her love is forever, because you told her some things are worth dying for. And she is always dying, because it takes a beautiful, poor, consumptive, uneducated woman dying to teach a self-absorbed, educated upper-middle-class man what love really means; pretty, tormented, fleeting and laced with dizzy spells and coughing fits. And you'll go on, because she's just a background, a tragic past, an origin story, a reminder never to value life so lightly again, so you can look back and think, I failed once and I shall not fail again. She is the Uncle Ben to your Peter Parker, the Marguerite to your Faust, the strength of your resolve.
 
 

I had a theory for all of this once, but it is not one that makes sense- I've been thinking that if you had not touched her, she would not have died, when the truth is, touching her or not, she was dying the instant you saw her, and would have died had you never seen her; but having never seen her, her death would have meant nothing to you, having never touched her, her death would have been a mere moment of regret, like the moment when you hear as a that the cutie who sat in the first row of your ninth-grade Latin was killed in a car accident recently; some pretty person already unreachable to you moved yet further away, and taken off the chessboard completely. But having known and touched her, her death assumes an air of tragedy, and that is something you can always hide behind and always be selfish because of and always, secretly, be grateful for.

 
 
Because she's more use to you dead than alive. 
 
 
 
Because when it came down to it, her love is a toy for the rich young man you are. You never could have brought her before your family. Because of what makes you love her and who she is isn't acceptable to them, never would be, and as you grow older and more rigid, you would hold that as a sword over her head, berate her for her former wildness, for her past, hold all her charming sins against her. You loved her because she was so different from the world you came from, she was so refreshingly blunt after those soft society women, you loved her because she knew no master. Yet you can not trust her because of the manner in which you found her and the very reasons you fell for her will work against her. Her air of mystery will make you insane with jealousy, her independence will make you a petty tyrant, her unfathomable eyes will cause you to read mockery in every gesture of her hands. You will doubt her, because she was never true to any other man. Very soon the glamour will wash her beauty from your eyes and you will be ashamed of your love. 
 
 
 

It's funny, really, that the death of good men in battle is fitting to me, for there is a sort of sad glory in it. The deaths that make me angry and bitter are these tiny deaths, the deaths of whores and actresses in the slums and back staircases of Art. They are only butterflies, and live for a day to die the next; they tell you as much when you meet them, but the men who court them live forever, and write plays about them, operas and films, convert their squalid little lives into the things of great beauty (and often, little sense) and all to celebrate the life of the woman they betrayed and estranged, the woman who had nothing and lost all and yet forgave them that betrayal.

 
 
 

I don't forgive you. I never will. I will never forgive Alfredo for driving Violetta mad. And more so, I will never forgive his father for asking her to sacrifice her life with her lover for a cold slow death in a Paris flophouse.

 
 
 
She was doomed the moment you caught sight of her. She was perfect, safe and iconic until you touched her, until by claiming her as your own you tainted her with individuality, with your mortality and hurtled her to her death with the taste, but not the substance of love. You held the chalice out to her, but would not let her drink from it.
 
 
And she understood, in her sad, dying eyes, and she never hated you, even when you vented your wounded pride upon her, even when you threw money at her and told her you never loved her.
 
 
And she understood, in her sad, dying eyes, and she never hated you, even when you vented your wounded pride upon her, even when you threw money at her and told her you never loved her.
 
 
But I hate you.
 
 
I hate you because one day you'll sing your pretty songs to someone else and one day you'll tell the story of the whore who died for love of you and everyone will weep for her sacrifices, and she who suffered will still be a corpse rotting in the ground. And you will never suffer. And you will never know anything about this woman you immortalized, nothing more than her face, the sound of her voice, the shape of her back, the curve of her neck, the taste of blood on her lips. She is gone and you never knew her. She is gone and you only knew her beauty.
 
 

I hate you because you told her she was worthy of love and understanding and abandoned her when she needed you most. For all the actresses, all the dancers, all the pretty whores and showgirls who were taken and broken on the wheel of love, for poor Maryanne, who decided to place her faith in young Wilhelm Meister on the very night he decided that she really was a two-timing slut, Maryanne who died alone, for all of them, who knew the world wasn't a bad place if you didn't expect too much from it, and then you come in and tell them that there are no limits, that love really is all you need, and you tell them this until they start to believe you, until they start to trust you, and then you leave and take this beautiful new purity with you when you go. And they never stop loving you, even knowing what they've lost, what you've denied them. Even knowing that in you, they only exchanged one pretty mask for another. To them, to be love is worth that steep a price.

 
 

But all I will ever see is that they loved you and you failed them. That they trusted you to understand, because you said you would always understand and you failed. That you said nothing would separate you, only to be torn away from her by your own pride. That when the chips where down you deserted the girl who loved you.

 
 

And you lied to yourself if you thought she was anything more or less than a girl. And she, for all her poverty and her sins, she outshone you to the last because she never doubted, she never wavered. When you met her she did not believe in love, and when you left her she was an apostle to your faith and martyred herself to it while you doubted, while you seethed with rage and jealousy and left her to face her death alone.

   
  Coward.
   
  And I'll never get the disease... because I've had it...
   
 
 
 
 
 
[home][write]